
Clarity Intelligence
Brand growth is a governance problem
The best marketing evidence assumes brands can hold a course for years. Most organisations can't, and the reason is governance, not media planning.

Two of the best-evidenced bodies of work in marketing tell leaders what a brand must build and how to pace the investment. Both assume something most organisations find hard: holding a course for years. Failing at it is a governance problem, and AI makes it harder to hide.
Most leadership teams now share a language for brand growth. Byron Sharp and the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute tell them what to build: a brand that is easy to think of and easy to buy. Les Binet and Peter Field tell them how to pace it: enough long-term brand building to grow, enough short-term activation to convert.
People often treat the two as rivals, but they answer different questions. Between them, they cover almost every lever a brand has, from distinctive assets and broad-reach campaigns to promotions and search.
Neither describes the organisation that has to pull those levers consistently, through changes in leadership, budget cycles, and owners. In my experience, that is where most brands lose ground, and the theory is rarely the reason.
What the evidence settled
Sharp's How Brands Grow (2010) argued that brands grow mainly by winning more buyers, not by deepening the loyalty of the ones they have. Two kinds of availability do the work. Mental availability is a brand's propensity to be noticed or come to mind in buying situations, as Romaniuk and Sharp defined in 2004. Physical availability is how easy the brand is to find and buy.
Romaniuk's Building Distinctive Brand Assets (2018) supplies the means: the colours, shapes, logos and other cues that link a brand to memory, built and protected over the long term.
Binet and Field's The Long and the Short of It (2013) analysed 996 campaigns entered into the IPA Effectiveness Awards between 1980 and 2010. Activation produced sharp but short-lived sales effects; brand building produced slower, more durable ones. On average, the most effective budgets split about 60% on brand building and 40% on activation. Their later analysis put the average at 62:38 and showed it varying by category, so treat the ratio as an average to start from.
The assumption underneath
Both frameworks assume continuity. Distinctive assets only work if they are used consistently for years, which is why Romaniuk treats their management as a management system, with checks that give early warning of problems. The brand–activation balance only pays if brand budgets survive the quarters in which they show little return.
Leadership rarely stays that long. Spencer Stuart's 2026 study puts average CMO tenure at S&P 500 companies at 4.1 years, against 5.0 years across the C-suite, and at 3.5 years in consumer companies. A well-managed distinctive asset can outlast several CMOs.
Incentives pull the same way. In a survey of 401 financial executives, Graham, Harvey and Rajgopal (2005) found that 78% would give up economic value to keep earnings smooth. More than half said they would pass on a clearly value-creating project if it meant missing the current quarter's consensus.
So when activation crowds out brand building, the cause is rarely a media-planning error. Binet and Field warned in 2017 that short-termism was eroding effectiveness across the IPA cases. The habit is set further upstream: by how the business makes money, what its owners expect and when, and what its people are paid to deliver. Fix the plan without fixing those drivers, and the next correction is only postponed.
Value creation starts before the brand
Brand value creation begins with a simpler question than growth: does what the organisation says match what actually drives it? Mission, values and brand promise are what it says. The commercial model, ownership expectations and incentives are what push it.
When the two align, the brand becomes a credible expression of the business, and investment in it compounds. When they disagree, the drivers win, and the brand becomes a promise the business keeps breaking.
Our CQ model reads value through four lenses, which we call value creators:
Inherent: whether the strategy is coherent in itself, with what is said matching what drives decisions.
Resonant: whether the meaning lands, so people recognise themselves in it and it shows in how the organisation presents itself.
Contextual: whether that meaning holds across teams, entities, markets and channels, or gets reinterpreted at each boundary.
Objective: whether clarity shows up in outcomes such as speed, cost, risk and performance.
Read against the growth frameworks, inherent and resonant value decide whether there is a brand worth making available. Contextual value decides whether it is delivered the same way at every point of contact, which is where physical availability is won or lost. Objective value is where the growth shows.
The levers nobody owns
The levers between mental and physical availability are often the most under-invested: packaging, retail partnerships, and how the brand shows up in store or in service. They work over both short and long horizons, but they fit neither a campaign brief nor a promotions budget, so they fall between functions.
That is a symptom of a wider pattern. When brand sits in one function, its owner is accountable for outcomes that depend on decisions made elsewhere: product, pricing, channel, service, hiring. The organisation keeps communicating the brand, but nobody is governing it.
Two moments are especially exposed. The first is the handover from strategy to execution, when the promise meets the culture that has to deliver it. The second is renewal, when results should feed back into purpose and the next plan. Usually they don't, because nobody re-measures.
Grupo Futuro, a diversified Ecuadorian group with more than 20 entities and over 5,300 employees, shows the pattern clearly. 2024 was the strongest financial year in its history. Each entity knew its own identity, but the meaning of the Group had been inherited from its founding chair—never written down— and was read differently across sectors and roles. It had strong financial governance, and no governance of its meaning.
Our 2025 Clarity Scan drew about 1,400 responses in 10 days. The Group's overall clarity score was high, at 83.8 out of 100, and the highest-scoring item was understanding of long-term direction. The lowest, at 61, was "We behave as one organisation, not separate entities." People understood where the Group was heading, but they didn't experience it as one organisation.
The programme that followed treats that meaning as something to govern, with a clarity governance model, an annual clarity cycle and clarity built into succession planning. That matters because a generational leadership transition is coming, and the Group's meaning can no longer rest on its founder.
What AI changes
AI matters to this argument in three ways.
AI as a place to be found
More buying journeys now start with an AI-written answer. Bain's late-2024 consumer survey found that about 80% of search users rely on AI summaries for at least 40% of their searches. Being easy to think of increasingly means being easy for a model to retrieve and recommend.
The early evidence suggests the old rules still hold. SparkToro and Gumshoe ran 2,961 prompts through ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI and found the same list of brands came back less than once in a hundred runs (Search Engine Land summary). Rank was close to noise. Which brands appeared at all was far more stable, which is how mental availability behaves: it is a probability spread across many buying situations.
A study by the agency Charlie Oscar, covering 30 large brands in six categories, attributed 63% of LLM visibility to long-term brand equity and 22% to current marketing spend. Its author calls the result directional, with wide error margins. It points the same way: models reflect years of consistent brand building more than this quarter's activity.
AI as an amplifier
AI systems build their picture of an organisation from everything it puts out: disclosures, leadership statements, employee reviews, media coverage, operational data. Where those signals agree, the picture sharpens. Where they contradict each other, they are discounted or interpreted without the organisation's input, as we argued in The AI brand architecture that actually holds. Generative tools inside the business do the same: they scale whatever brand guidance they are given, coherent or not.
AI as a measuring instrument
The same technology makes it possible to measure what used to be anecdotal. CQiO, our clarity-intelligence platform at cqio.ai, scores 48 behavioural signals across six dimensions, analyses open-text responses for themes and tone, and flags drift between measurement waves. It is built for the step most brand programmes skip: measuring again.
Four questions for the next planning cycle
A growth plan that audits only media and channels checks half the system. Four questions cover the rest:
Does what we say match what actually drives us: our commercial model, our owners' time horizon and our incentives?
Are we building mental and physical availability across enough buyers, with a brand–activation balance that suits our category and stage?
Who owns each lever, including the ones between brand and sales, and do those decision rights survive a change of CMO, CEO or owner?
Besides campaign results, are we re-measuring clarity across entities and roles, and our presence in AI-generated answers?
Sharp, Binet and Field have given marketers sound answers about what grows a brand. Whether an organisation keeps doing those things long enough for them to work is a question for its leadership and its board.
If any of this is recognisable in your organisation, we'd welcome the conversation.
Disclosure and sources
Firstwater Advisory developed the CQ model and the CQiO platform. CQ is a practitioner framework and has not yet been independently validated in published research.
Bain & Company (2025, 19 February). Consumer reliance on AI search results signals new era of marketing. Press release.
Binet, L. and Field, P. (2013). The Long and the Short of It: Balancing Short and Long-Term Marketing Strategies. London: IPA.
Binet, L. and Field, P. (2017). Media in Focus: Marketing Effectiveness in the Digital Era. London: IPA.
Binet, L. and Field, P. (2018). Effectiveness in Context. London: IPA. Summarised in IPA, "The next chapter for The Long and the Short of It".
Fishkin, R. and O'Donnell, P. (2026, January). AIs are highly inconsistent when recommending brands or products. SparkToro and Gumshoe.ai.
Graham, J. R., Harvey, C. R. and Rajgopal, S. (2005). The economic implications of corporate financial reporting. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 40(1–3), 3–73.
Romaniuk, J. (2018). Building Distinctive Brand Assets. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
Romaniuk, J. and Sharp, B. (2004). Conceptualising and measuring brand salience. Marketing Theory, 4(4), 327–342.
Sharp, B. (2010). How Brands Grow: What Marketers Don't Know. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
Spencer Stuart (2026, January). CMO tenure 2026: snapshot of an expanding role for marketing leaders.
Wilson, D. (2026, 22 January). AEO, GEO, LLM search, AI search: should marketers actually care? Charlie Oscar.
Firstwater Advisory (2025). Grupo Futuro case study.
